The University of California Riverside’s College of Engineering – Center for Environmental Research and Technology (CE-CERT) has released a report that summarises clear benefits should California promote the uptake of heavy duty natural gas trucks to meet its objective of reducing transport-related emissions, particularly when compared to equivalent diesel-operated HDVs. It sees natural gas powered vehicles as significant contributors that will assist the South Coast Air Basin and California to reach federal air quality attainment standards.
The new report found that new ultra-low emission natural gas heavy-duty vehicles met and exceeded their certification standards during a full range of duty cycles. This finding is in stark contrast to previously released CE-CERT data and a recently released report by the California Air Resources Board that found heavy-duty diesel trucks emitted higher levels of NOx than their certification standards in the same duty cycles.
“When comparing the data of the cleanest available heavy-duty diesel vehicles versus the cleanest available heavy-duty natural vehicles, it is clear that natural gas vehicles provide unmatched reductions of smog-forming emissions,” stated Dr. Kent Johnson, author of the report. “These near-zero emission natural gas vehicles are especially effective in applications that require low speeds, such as short-haul goods movement.”
Diesel-fueled medium- and heavy-duty vehicles are the number one source of smog-forming emissions of nitrogen oxides (NOx) in almost every single metropolitan region in the country. NOx emissions lead to the formation of ozone and small particulate matter (PM2.5), each of which contributes to significant health impacts, including asthma and heart disease. In areas with the most severe air quality problems – such as southern and central California – achieving healthy air quality will require a transition of heavy-duty vehicles to ones that emit zero or near-zero emissions.
The Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) has systematically reduced the allowable emissions of NOx from new heavy-duty engines since 1994 through application of progressively lower federal standards. With the 2010 NOx certification limit of 0.2g/bhp-hr, NOx emissions dropped 90% compared to 2006 and older heavy-duty vehicles. Additional NOx reductions of another 90% are desired for the South Coast Air Basin to meet its 2023 NOx inventory requirements.
A report authored by CE-CERT’s Dr. Kent Johnson (PI) evaluated the Cummins Westport ISL G near-zero (NZ) engine emissions during typical in-use conditions. The engine was certified in the fall of 2016 by the EPA and the California Air Resources Board (CARB) to 0.02 g/bhp-hr, which is 90% cleaner than EPA’s current NOx emission standard and 90% cleaner than the cleanest available diesel engine.
The report tested the ISL G near-zero engine on duty cycles that represent operations in the South Coast Air Basin. These cycles included the urban dynamometer driving schedule (i.e., city driving conditions), port cycles (including near dock, local and regional), refuse cycles, and central business district cycles. The report concludes that ISL G near-zero natural gas engines perform with NOx emissions below their certification level and that emissions decrease as the duty cycles decrease, meaning that in lower speed scenarios, such as stop-and-go traffic commonly found throughout the South Coast region, the emissions decreased.
A separate report published in 2013 by the same author evaluated the in-use emissions of heavy-duty diesel vehicles with modern emission control systems in the same duty cycles found that the diesel engines performed with up to 5 times higher NOx emissions on average than their EPA certification standard and emissions increased as the duty cycle decreased. A report released in October 2016 by the California Air Resources Board (CARB) reported similar findings – that in-use NOx emissions from heavy-duty diesel trucks were 1.7 to 9 times higher than the NOx certification standard. As the UCR and CARB reports found, these high in-use NOx emissions occurred primarily during low speed operations, which is a concern in California where low speed operations are common, such as near port operations.
- Fact sheet on the ultra-low NOx natural gas vehicle evaluation report: www.cert.ucr.edu/research/efr/NOx-Fact-Sheet.pdf
- Full report of the ultra-low NOx natural gas vehicle evaluation: www.cert.ucr.edu/research/efr/2016%20CWI%20LowNOx%20NG_Finalv06.pdf
- Previously released CE-CERT report on HD diesel trucks: www.cert.ucr.edu/research/efr/2013_AQMD_in-use_retrofit_Miller.pdf
(Source: University of California, Riverside)